You're in Candy

Narrow Search Results

  • Price Range

    $ to $
    Update>>
  • By Product Group

    By Candy Flavor

    By Candy Name

    By Occasions & Themes

    By Keyword

    Zagnut Candy Bars 18 Count Old Fashioned Candy Zagnut Coconut Peanut Butter Bars

    Zagnut Candy Bars 18 Count Old Fashioned Candy Zagnut Coconut Peanut Butter Bars

    candymafia Store Payment We gladly combine shipping on all of our items. Sometimes ebay has trouble combining the shipping when you order different flavors from us, so just let us know and we'll gladly adjust it. :) Shipping We will gladly combine... more

    $24.97

    FREE shipping

    go to store
    5 Full Pounds Peanut Butter Bars Candy Bulk Old Fashioned Fav Free Ship

    5 Full Pounds Peanut Butter Bars Candy Bulk Old Fashioned Fav Free Ship

    div style="text-align:center"img src="http://ti2.auctiva.com/sw/java.gif" border="0"br table align="center"tr td a style="text-decoration:none" href="http://emporium.auctiva.com/partyallthetimeballoon" target="_blank"img... more

    $26.99

    FREE shipping

    go to store
    Honeycomb Peanuts 2lbs Same Great Old Fashioned Peanutbutter Taste Atkinson

    Honeycomb Peanuts 2lbs Same Great Old Fashioned Peanutbutter Taste Atkinson

    Honeycomb Peanuts by Atkinson 2Lbs These peanut shaped candies are light and crunchy with a honeycomb texture. Real peanut butter is then awaiting you in the center. They have been around for decades and were joyfully found in Christmas stockings by... more

    $17.08

    FREE shipping

    go to store
    Miles Kimball Mary Jane Candies

    Miles Kimball Mary Jane Candies

    Original Mary Janes candies are the old fashioned peanut butter candy that will surprise and delight your guests! This sweet peanut buttery treat with a hint of molasses will remind you of the good ol' days. Nostalgic 10 oz. tin measures 4 1/4" x 6". more

    $12.98

    FREE shipping

    go to store
    Miles Kimball Hammond's Filled Peanut Candy

    Miles Kimball Hammond's Filled Peanut Candy

    With smooth, hard-candy shell and creamy peanut butter filling, these luscious, peanut-shaped Hammonds candy are still made the old-fashioned way ... rekindling your sweetest candy counter memories. Each individually wrapped Hammonds filled peanut... more

    $14.98

    FREE shipping

    go to store
    Pennsylvania Dutch Candies Peanut Butter Pillows, 10-Ounces Tins (Pack of 4)

    Pennsylvania Dutch Candies Peanut Butter Pillows, 10-Ounces Tins (Pack of 4)

    Try this old-fashioned favorite: Freshly ground peanut butter coated with a thin candy shell more

    $26.03

    go to store
    Mary Janes Old Fashioned Candy, 5 Pound

    Mary Janes Old Fashioned Candy, 5 Pound

    This chewy molases and peanut butter candy was first made in 1914. And it's still as yummy as ever. There are approximately 60 pieces per pound. Case contains 5 pounds of Mary Janes Candy. Made by NECCO. more

    $26.19

    go to store
    Mary Janes Old Fashioned Candy, 1 Pound

    Mary Janes Old Fashioned Candy, 1 Pound

    This chewy molases and peanut butter candy was first made in 1914. And it's still as yummy as ever. There are approximately 60 pieces per pound. Case contains 5 pounds of Mary Janes Candy. Made by NECCO. more

    $8.91

    go to store
    Circus Peanuts Old Fashioned Candy 2 Lbs

    Circus Peanuts Old Fashioned Candy 2 Lbs

    Circus Peanuts ~ Old Fashioned Candy ~ 2 Lbs 2 lbs of the original Spangler Circus Peanuts Candy Unique treat features peanut shaped marshmallows with an orange color and banana flavor A classic fat free candy that has been around for decades and is... more

    $10.55

    go to store
    2 Lb Necco Mary Jane Old Fashioned Candy Bulk

    2 Lb Necco Mary Jane Old Fashioned Candy Bulk

    2 LB Necco Mary Jane Old Fashioned Candy BULK Mary Jane's have been a favorite for the past 85 years with children young and old. Take one bite of these chewy sweet candies, flavored with molasses and peanut butter, and you'll see why this classic... more

    $6.99

    go to store
    Old Fashion Peanut Butter Fudge Smooth Creamy 1 Pound

    Old Fashion Peanut Butter Fudge Smooth Creamy 1 Pound

    Powered by Frooition Pro Shop Search Old Fashion Peanut Butter Fudge smooth creamy 1 pound Click here to view full size. Full Size Image Click to close full size. Item Description This Peanut Butter fudge is like something out of Grandma's Kitchen. It... more

    $10.95

    go to store
    Old Dominion Butter Peanut Crunch 4 oz. Peg Bag, 24 Bags/Box

    Old Dominion Butter Peanut Crunch 4 oz. Peg Bag, 24 Bags/Box

    Peanut flavor,4 oz. Peg Bag ,24 Peg Bags per order ,Gluten Free,Kosher Certified,Made in the USA, , more

    $34.95

    go to store
    Old Fashion Peanut Butter Fudge: 6LB Case

    Old Fashion Peanut Butter Fudge: 6LB Case

    Old Fashion Peanut Butter Fudge: 6LB Case Milk chocolate fudge swirled with peanut butter fudge. Flavor: Chocolate more

    $49.95

    go to store
    M&M's Peanut Butter Chocolate Candies: 24 Count

    M&M's Peanut Butter Chocolate Candies: 24 Count

    M&M's get the peanut treatment and the results are predictably glorious. A nutty, milk chocolatey twist on an old classic everyone will enjoy. more

    $24.95

    go to store
    SweetGourmet Old Dominion Peanut Brittle, 16 Oz, 1lb

    SweetGourmet Old Dominion Peanut Brittle, 16 Oz, 1lb

    Peanut Brittle is a thin, crispy, melt-in-your-mouth product originating from a recipe developed 95 years ago! A generous amount of premium peanuts and other quality ingredients go in to every batch of this old-fashioned candy. more

    $9.44

    go to store
    Carolyn's Handmade Gourmet Diamond Tin, Peanut Brittle, Small, 10.5 Ounce

    Carolyn's Handmade Gourmet Diamond Tin, Peanut Brittle, Small, 10.5 Ounce

    Our tasty old south brittle is made from scratch, the old fashioned way. In small copper kettles, we hand stir the brittle until it is the right consistency, fold in lots of peanuts, and then, pour the brittle out on marble tables to cool. The result... more

    $40.50

    FREE shipping

    go to store
    Carolyn's Handmade Peanut Brittle Bulk, 160 Ounce (=10 lbs)

    Carolyn's Handmade Peanut Brittle Bulk, 160 Ounce (=10 lbs)

    Our tasty old south brittle is made from scratch, the old fashioned way. In small copper kettles, we hand stir the brittle until it is the right consistency, fold in lots of peanuts, and then, pour the brittle out on marble tables to cool. The result... more

    $45.16

    FREE shipping

    go to store
    Old Fashioned Peanut Brittle Squares - 24 Count

    Old Fashioned Peanut Brittle Squares - 24 Count

    Peanut brittle is a Southern tradition, and at Atkinson Candy Company they use a secret family recipe handed down from generation to generation. Their Old Fashion Peanut Brittle features a rich buttery base mixed with Texas Grade A Jumbo peanuts to... more

    $21.95

    go to store
    Old Dominion Butter Peanut Crunch 4 oz. Peg Bag, 24 Bags/Box

    Old Dominion Butter Peanut Crunch 4 oz. Peg Bag, 24 Bags/Box

    Peanut flavor,4 oz. Peg Bag ,24 Peg Bags per order ,Gluten Free,Kosher Certified,Made in the USA, , more

    $34.95

    go to store

    Candy.com

    (2,500+)
    Pennsylvania Dutch Candies Dutch Treat Peanut Butter Pillows - 10 o...

    Pennsylvania Dutch Candies Dutch Treat Peanut Butter Pillows - 10 o...

    Pennsylvania Dutch Candies Dutch Treat Peanut Butter Pillows, 4 pkTry this old-fashioned favorite: Freshly ground peanut butter coated with a thin candy shellFour 10 ounce tinsKosher certifiedEasy to eat more

    $24.99 $19.85

    go to store
    Old Fashioned Peanut Brittle 24 count

    Old Fashioned Peanut Brittle 24 count

    Snap into a deliciously nutty, peanut buttery treat. more

    $24.39

    go to store
    Old fashioned rum and butter candy sticks 80ct.

    Old fashioned rum and butter candy sticks 80ct.

    Yellow, Rum and Butter flavored Candy Sticks. Individually wrapped Old Fashioned Candy Sticks are perfect for wedding buffets, conventions, parties, color-themed events, showers and holidays! 80 - 5 1/2" old fashioned hard candy sticks per box.... more

    $14.94

    go to store
    Mary Jane Tubs, 240 Pieces/tub

    Mary Jane Tubs, 240 Pieces/tub

    Capacity: 240 pieces.Peanut butter and molasses chews.5 lb. bulk.Individually wrapped.Gluten-Free.Made in the USA.Mary Jane Chews offer old-fashioned peanut butter and molasses chews. more

    $22.09

    go to store
    Old Dominion Peanut Butter Brittlecorn 8oz Bags: 6 ct

    Old Dominion Peanut Butter Brittlecorn 8oz Bags: 6 ct

    Old Dominion Peanut Butter Brittlecorn 8oz Bags: 6 ct more

    $59.95

    go to store

    Candy.com

    (2,500+)
    Old Dominion Butter Peanut Crunch 4 oz. Peg Bag, 24 Bags/Box

    Old Dominion Butter Peanut Crunch 4 oz. Peg Bag, 24 Bags/Box

    Peanut flavor,4 oz. Peg Bag ,24 Peg Bags per order ,Gluten Free,Kosher Certified,Made in the USA, , more

    $34.95

    go to store
    Old-Fashioned Bridge Mix: Snack Nuts at Figi's

    Old-Fashioned Bridge Mix: Snack Nuts at Figi's

    Snack Nuts: Delicious treasures Peanuts, Raisins, Dark Chocolate Cremes, Caramels, Malted Milk Balls, Lemon Cremes, and Brazil Nuts are locked inside smooth coatings of milk and dark chocolate. Net wt. 13 oz. more

    $16.99

    go to store

    Figi's

    (25,000+)
    M&M's Peanut Butter Chocolate Candies: 24 Count

    M&M's Peanut Butter Chocolate Candies: 24 Count

    M&M's get the peanut treatment and the results are predictably glorious. A nutty, milk chocolatey twist on an old classic everyone will enjoy. more

    $24.95

    go to store
    M&M's Peanut Butter Chocolate Candies: 24 Count

    M&M's Peanut Butter Chocolate Candies: 24 Count

    M&M's get the peanut treatment and the results are predictably glorious. A nutty, milk chocolatey twist on an old classic everyone will enjoy. more

    $24.95

    go to store

    Candy.com

    (2,500+)
    Old Dominion Butter Toffee, 4 oz. Peg Bag, 24 Bags/Box

    Old Dominion Butter Toffee, 4 oz. Peg Bag, 24 Bags/Box

    Toffee flavor,4 oz. Peg Bag ,24 Peg Bags per order ,Gluten Free,Kosher Certified,Made in the USA, , more

    $34.95

    go to store
    Hammond's Filled Peanut Candy, Yellow

    Hammond's Filled Peanut Candy, Yellow

    Hammond's Filled Peanut Candy, Yellow. Hammond's Filled Peanut Candy. With smooth, hard-candy shell and creamy peanut butter filling, these luscious, peanut-shaped Hammond's candy are still made the old-fashioned way ... rekindling your sweetest candy... more

    $11.99

    go to store
    (5,000+)
    Pennsylvania Dutch Candies Peanut Brittle - 8 oz

    Pennsylvania Dutch Candies Peanut Brittle - 8 oz

    Peanut brittle is a Southern tradition, and the folks of Atkinson's Candy use a secret family recipe handed down from generation to generation. Their Old Fashioned Peanut Brittle features a rich buttery base mixed with Texas Grade A Jumbo peanuts to... more

    $15.99 $13.40

    go to store
    Peanut Brittle Gift - 12 Oz.

    Peanut Brittle Gift - 12 Oz.

    Old fashioned peanut brittle is a classic seasonal treat. Enjoy the crunchy favorite--without having to make it yourself. Our peanut brittle is cooked in copper kettles from a decades-old recipe, boasting exceptional taste and texture. 2" H x 6 1/2"... more

    $14.99

    go to store
    (2,500+)
    Abba Zaba Candy Bar Chunks 500 ct

    Abba Zaba Candy Bar Chunks 500 ct

    Old-fashioned candy bar chunks made with thick, white chewy taffy, with a rich creamy peanut butter filling in the center. Abba-Zaba Candy Bars come in a 500ct Box Kosher Certified! more

    $99.95

    go to store
    Abba Zaba Candy Bars, 24ct.

    Abba Zaba Candy Bars, 24ct.

    Old-fashioned Abba Zaba candy bars made with thick, white chewy taffy, with a rich creamy peanut butter filling in the center. Abba-Zabba Candy bars come in a 24ct Box Kosher Certified! more

    $23.95

    go to store
    Chick O Stick

    Chick O Stick

    The ChickOStick from Atkinson is a great treat for young and old alike. Many like the flavor of this as it has crunchy peanut butter for the peanut butter lover and a roasted coconut coating. Order your ChickOStick for a great lasting taste in your... more

    $8.99

    go to store
    Chick-O-Stick

    Chick-O-Stick

    The Chick-O-Stick from Atkinson is a great treat for young and old alike. Many like the flavor of this as it has crunchy peanut butter for the peanut butter lover and a roasted coconut coating. Order your Chick-O-Stick for a great lasting taste in your... more

    $7.99

    go to store
    Chick-O-Stick

    Chick-O-Stick

    The Chick-O-Stick from Atkinson is a great treat for young and old alike. Many like the flavor of this as it has crunchy peanut butter for the peanut butter lover and a roasted coconut coating. Order your Chick-O-Stick for a great lasting taste in your... more

    $7.95

    go to store
    Bassetts Murray Mints Jar 1.5kg

    Bassetts Murray Mints Jar 1.5kg

    The Murray Mint is a good old fashioned traditional hard boiled sweet from sweet experts Bassetts. Murray Mints have a distinctive flavour, which perfectly combines mint and butter for that creamy taste. more

    $26.61

    go to store
    Easter Bucket of Brittle: Candy at Figi's

    Easter Bucket of Brittle: Candy at Figi's

    Candy: Better than an Easter basket, this generous bucket of old-fashioned Peanut Brittle is a wonderful way to send your Easter greetings! Melt-inyour-mouth delight, chock-a-block withfresh peanutsenough for the most avid brittle lovers! Net wt. 1 lb.... more

    $24.99

    go to store

    Figi's

    (25,000+)

    More information about Candy

    Best prices on Old fashioned peanut butter in Candy online. Visit Bizrate to find the best deals on top brands. Read reviews on Gifts, Flowers & Food merchants and buy with confidence.
    Show
    Hide
    Hide