You're in Candy

Need a Personal Shopper?

Subscribe to
Bizrate emails for the hottest
deals & products
,
PLUS a chance to

WIN $25

sign me up!

New winners chosen weekly.
No purchase necessary.

Fralinger's Peanut Butter Taffy Chews Candy: 12-Ounce Box

Fralinger's Peanut Butter Taffy Chews Candy: 12-Ounce Box

Made from a prized Fralinger's family recipe! First, they take molasses salt water taffy, flavored with real, old fashioned molasses, and fill it with, not one, but two, peanut butter centers - one creamy and one chunky. Fralinger's unique secret blend...

at CandyWarehouse.com

Nips Peanut Butter Parfait Candy, 4-Ounce Boxes (Pack of 12)

Nips Peanut Butter Parfait Candy, 4-Ounce Boxes (Pack of 12)

Nestle Nips Candy is the rich and creamy hard candy that provides a soothing diversion. Each nips candy has its own distinct and truly satisfying flavor. ... more

Nips Peanut Butter Parfait Candy, 4-Ounce Boxes (Pack of 12)

Nestle Nips Candy is the rich and creamy hard candy that provides a soothing diversion. Each nips candy has its own distinct and truly satisfying flavor.

$26.69

go to store
Nestle Nips Peanut Butter Candy, Pearson - 4 Oz /Box, 12 Ea

Nestle Nips Peanut Butter Candy, Pearson - 4 Oz /Box, 12 Ea

MANUFACTURER: NESTLE . INDICATIONS: Nestle Nips Peanut Butter Candy, Pearson Rich & creamy hard candy. Creamy Creamy caramel shell over rich peanut butter centers. For over 75 years, there has been one candy that is extraordinarily rich. Smooth,... ... more

Nestle Nips Peanut Butter Candy, Pearson - 4 Oz /Box, 12 Ea

MANUFACTURER: NESTLE . INDICATIONS: Nestle Nips Peanut Butter Candy, Pearson Rich & creamy hard candy. Creamy Creamy caramel shell over rich peanut butter centers. For over 75 years, there has been one candy that is extraordinarily rich. Smooth,...

$25.65

FREE shipping

go to store
M&M's Peanut Butter Chocolate Candy Theater Box, 3.4 Ounce (Pack of 12)

M&M's Peanut Butter Chocolate Candy Theater Box, 3.4 Ounce (Pack of 12)

Enjoy the classic that’s loved around the world! M&M'S have been one of the most famous candy treats in the world since 1941. The snack-sized pieces of chocolate in a colorful candy shell are instantly recognizable all over the globe. Perfect for... ... more

M&M's Peanut Butter Chocolate Candy Theater Box, 3.4 Ounce (Pack of 12)

Enjoy the classic that’s loved around the world! M&M'S have been one of the most famous candy treats in the world since 1941. The snack-sized pieces of chocolate in a colorful candy shell are instantly recognizable all over the globe. Perfect for...

$17.98

go to store
M&M'S Peanut Butter Chocolate Candy Singles Size 1.63-Ounce Pouch 24-Count Box

M&M'S Peanut Butter Chocolate Candy Singles Size 1.63-Ounce Pouch 24-Count Box

This iconic candy only gets better with bites of chocolate candy and real creamy peanut butter in singles size pouches. Enjoy snack-sized pieces of chocolate-covered peanut butter that are coated with a colorful candy shell. Peanut Butter M&M'S Candy... ... more

M&M'S Peanut Butter Chocolate Candy Singles Size 1.63-Ounce Pouch 24-Count Box

This iconic candy only gets better with bites of chocolate candy and real creamy peanut butter in singles size pouches. Enjoy snack-sized pieces of chocolate-covered peanut butter that are coated with a colorful candy shell. Peanut Butter M&M'S Candy...

$11.43

go to store
Reese's Pieces Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count

Reese's Pieces Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count

REESE'S' PIECES' Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count It's E.T.'s favorite candy! These peanut butter discs with crunchy candy shells sport bright yellow, orange, and brown color. Each order includes 12 REESE'S' PIECES' Candy Theater Boxes. Kosher Certified... ... more

Reese's Pieces Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count

REESE'S' PIECES' Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count It's E.T.'s favorite candy! These peanut butter discs with crunchy candy shells sport bright yellow, orange, and brown color. Each order includes 12 REESE'S' PIECES' Candy Theater Boxes. Kosher Certified...

$19.95

go to store
Ddi 1266812 Squirrel Nut Zipper Chews 5 Oz. Bag Case Of 12

Ddi 1266812 Squirrel Nut Zipper Chews 5 Oz. Bag Case Of 12

Squirrel Nut Zipper Chews Chewy peanut caramel candy from NeccoVanilla nut caramel5 ounce bag for this candy ... more

Ddi 1266812 Squirrel Nut Zipper Chews 5 Oz. Bag Case Of 12

Squirrel Nut Zipper Chews Chewy peanut caramel candy from NeccoVanilla nut caramel5 ounce bag for this candy

SHOP.COM

$36.11 $27.78

go to store
Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count Butterfinger in concession box. These crispy peanut butter candy covered in chocolate are coming to you in concession box. Make yourself at home, start a movie, and enjoy these fabulous Butterfinger... ... more

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count Butterfinger in concession box. These crispy peanut butter candy covered in chocolate are coming to you in concession box. Make yourself at home, start a movie, and enjoy these fabulous Butterfinger...

$19.95

go to store
Nips Candy Boxes - Peanut Butter - 4 oz

Nips Candy Boxes - Peanut Butter - 4 oz

Nestle Nips Candy is the rich and creamy hard candy that provides a soothing diversion. Each nips candy has its own distinct and truly satisfying flavor.Features include: -Pack of twelve, 4-ounce boxes (total of 48-ounces) -Rich and creamy-Hard candy ... more

Nips Candy Boxes - Peanut Butter - 4 oz

Nestle Nips Candy is the rich and creamy hard candy that provides a soothing diversion. Each nips candy has its own distinct and truly satisfying flavor.Features include: -Pack of twelve, 4-ounce boxes (total of 48-ounces) -Rich and creamy-Hard candy

Soap.com

$15.99 $13.40

go to store
Peanut Butter Ginger Chews, 1.5 oz. Bag, 12 Bags/Box

Peanut Butter Ginger Chews, 1.5 oz. Bag, 12 Bags/Box

Peanut Butter Ginger flavor,1.5 oz. Bags ,12 Bags per order ,All Natural,Vegan,Gluten Free, Nut Free, Made in Indonesia ... more

Peanut Butter Ginger Chews, 1.5 oz. Bag, 12 Bags/Box

Peanut Butter Ginger flavor,1.5 oz. Bags ,12 Bags per order ,All Natural,Vegan,Gluten Free, Nut Free, Made in Indonesia

$24.95

go to store
Peanut Butter Ginger Chews, 1.5 oz. Bag, 12 Bags/Box

Peanut Butter Ginger Chews, 1.5 oz. Bag, 12 Bags/Box

Peanut Butter Ginger flavor,1.5 oz. Bags ,12 Bags per order ,All Natural,Vegan,Gluten Free, Nut Free, Made in Indonesia ... more

Peanut Butter Ginger Chews, 1.5 oz. Bag, 12 Bags/Box

Peanut Butter Ginger flavor,1.5 oz. Bags ,12 Bags per order ,All Natural,Vegan,Gluten Free, Nut Free, Made in Indonesia

Candy.com

$24.95

go to store
Peanut Butter Ginger Chews; 1.5 oz. Pack, 12 Packs/Box

Peanut Butter Ginger Chews; 1.5 oz. Pack, 12 Packs/Box

Peanut Butter Ginger flavor. 1.5 oz. Bags ... more

Peanut Butter Ginger Chews; 1.5 oz. Pack, 12 Packs/Box

Peanut Butter Ginger flavor. 1.5 oz. Bags

Quill

$23.99

go to store
Bourbon Balls Rum Peanut Butter Oreo Chocolate Candies Christmas Variety Box

Bourbon Balls Rum Peanut Butter Oreo Chocolate Candies Christmas Variety Box

Hello ! Thank you for looking ! Holiday SPECIAL!Assorted box of Holiday Chocolates: -3 Kentucky Bourbon balls,-3 Creamy Peanut Butter Balls,-3Delicious Rum balls ,-3 Chocolate Oreo Balls ! You will get total of 12 delicious candies.Great as a gift! I... ... more

Bourbon Balls Rum Peanut Butter Oreo Chocolate Candies Christmas Variety Box

Hello ! Thank you for looking ! Holiday SPECIAL!Assorted box of Holiday Chocolates: -3 Kentucky Bourbon balls,-3 Creamy Peanut Butter Balls,-3Delicious Rum balls ,-3 Chocolate Oreo Balls ! You will get total of 12 delicious candies.Great as a gift! I...

eBay

$15.99

go to store
Peanut Butter Balls Chocolate Candy Cookie Yummy Edible Holiday Gift Box

Peanut Butter Balls Chocolate Candy Cookie Yummy Edible Holiday Gift Box

Hello! Welcome to PetitCookieShop!The order is for 12 or 9 delicious and beautiful Peanut Butter Balls.They are made with peanut butter, butter,Vanilla extract,sugar , then rolled in chocolate.If that is a gift,please let me know and I will include a... ... more

Peanut Butter Balls Chocolate Candy Cookie Yummy Edible Holiday Gift Box

Hello! Welcome to PetitCookieShop!The order is for 12 or 9 delicious and beautiful Peanut Butter Balls.They are made with peanut butter, butter,Vanilla extract,sugar , then rolled in chocolate.If that is a gift,please let me know and I will include a...

eBay

$9.99

go to store
2 (two) Bags Reeses Pieces Peanut Butter Chocolate Candy Easter Eggs Exp 4/2016

2 (two) Bags Reeses Pieces Peanut Butter Chocolate Candy Easter Eggs Exp 4/2016

REESES PIECES Peanut Butter Eggs 2 Bags of Reeses Pieces in Egg shape.24 ounces total. (12 ounces each bag)These are the milk chocolate peanut butter pieces covered in a crisp shell with an egg shape.Brand new fresh stock, these expire April /2016.As... ... more

2 (two) Bags Reeses Pieces Peanut Butter Chocolate Candy Easter Eggs Exp 4/2016

REESES PIECES Peanut Butter Eggs 2 Bags of Reeses Pieces in Egg shape.24 ounces total. (12 ounces each bag)These are the milk chocolate peanut butter pieces covered in a crisp shell with an egg shape.Brand new fresh stock, these expire April /2016.As...

eBay

$20.00

FREE shipping

go to store
Reese's Pieces Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count

Reese's Pieces Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count

REESE'S' PIECES' Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count It's E.T.'s favorite candy! These peanut butter discs with crunchy candy shells sport bright yellow, orange, and brown color. Each order includes 12 REESE'S' PIECES' Candy Theater Boxes. Kosher Certified... ... more

Reese's Pieces Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count

REESE'S' PIECES' Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count It's E.T.'s favorite candy! These peanut butter discs with crunchy candy shells sport bright yellow, orange, and brown color. Each order includes 12 REESE'S' PIECES' Candy Theater Boxes. Kosher Certified...

Candy.com

$19.95

go to store
Reese's Pieces Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count

Reese's Pieces Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count

REESE’S® PIECES® Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count It's E.T.'s favorite candy! These peanut butter discs with crunchy candy shells sport bright yellow, orange, and brown color. Each order includes 12 REESE’S® PIECES® Candy Theater Boxes. Kosher Certified... ... more

Reese's Pieces Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count

REESE’S® PIECES® Candy 4 oz. Box: 12 Count It's E.T.'s favorite candy! These peanut butter discs with crunchy candy shells sport bright yellow, orange, and brown color. Each order includes 12 REESE’S® PIECES® Candy Theater Boxes. Kosher Certified...

$19.95

go to store
Abba Zaba 2 oz 24 Count Box

Abba Zaba 2 oz 24 Count Box

Abba Zaba 2 oz 24 Count Box : Abba Zaba 2 oz 24 Count Box : Chewy taffy filled with a peanut butter center. Each candy bar is 2 oz. ... more

Abba Zaba 2 oz 24 Count Box

Abba Zaba 2 oz 24 Count Box : Abba Zaba 2 oz 24 Count Box : Chewy taffy filled with a peanut butter center. Each candy bar is 2 oz.

Groovy Candies

$22.95

go to store
Abba Zaba Candy Bar Chunks 500 ct

Abba Zaba Candy Bar Chunks 500 ct

Old-fashioned candy bar chunks made with thick, white chewy taffy, with a rich creamy peanut butter filling in the center. Abba-Zaba Candy Bars come in a 500ct Box Kosher Certified! ... more

Abba Zaba Candy Bar Chunks 500 ct

Old-fashioned candy bar chunks made with thick, white chewy taffy, with a rich creamy peanut butter filling in the center. Abba-Zaba Candy Bars come in a 500ct Box Kosher Certified!

BestBuyCandy.com

$99.95

go to store
Abba Zaba Candy Bars, 24ct.

Abba Zaba Candy Bars, 24ct.

Old-fashioned Abba Zaba candy bars made with thick, white chewy taffy, with a rich creamy peanut butter filling in the center. Abba-Zabba Candy bars come in a 24ct Box Kosher Certified! ... more

Abba Zaba Candy Bars, 24ct.

Old-fashioned Abba Zaba candy bars made with thick, white chewy taffy, with a rich creamy peanut butter filling in the center. Abba-Zabba Candy bars come in a 24ct Box Kosher Certified!

BestBuyCandy.com

$23.95

go to store
Hershey Company, The Reese's Pieces Thtr Box 12 Pack

Hershey Company, The Reese's Pieces Thtr Box 12 Pack

Reese's Pieces Theater Box *4 Oz. *great Brand Of Reese's Pieces Available In A Convenient Box *great For On The Go Snacking *peanut Butter Candy In A Crunchy Shell *box ... more

Hershey Company, The Reese's Pieces Thtr Box 12 Pack

Reese's Pieces Theater Box *4 Oz. *great Brand Of Reese's Pieces Available In A Convenient Box *great For On The Go Snacking *peanut Butter Candy In A Crunchy Shell *box

Hardware Distributors

$13.20

go to store
Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count Butterfinger in concession box. These crispy peanut butter candy covered in chocolate are coming to you in concession box. Make yourself at home, start a movie, and enjoy these fabulous Butterfinger... ... more

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count Butterfinger in concession box. These crispy peanut butter candy covered in chocolate are coming to you in concession box. Make yourself at home, start a movie, and enjoy these fabulous Butterfinger...

Candy.com

$19.95

go to store
Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count Butterfinger in concession box. These crispy peanut butter candy covered in chocolate are coming to you in concession box. Make yourself at home, start a movie, and enjoy these fabulous Butterfinger... ... more

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count

Butterfinger Concession 3.5oz Box: 12 Count Butterfinger in concession box. These crispy peanut butter candy covered in chocolate are coming to you in concession box. Make yourself at home, start a movie, and enjoy these fabulous Butterfinger...

$19.95

go to store
Reese's Pieces Theater Size-12 Boxes

Reese's Pieces Theater Size-12 Boxes

"Reese's Pieces Theater Size-12 Boxes : Reese's Pieces Theater Size-12 Boxes : Reese's peanut butter covered with a crunchy candy shell in a theater size box. These come in 3 colors: Brown, Orange and Yellow. Each box contains approximately 150 pieces." ... more

Reese's Pieces Theater Size-12 Boxes

"Reese's Pieces Theater Size-12 Boxes : Reese's Pieces Theater Size-12 Boxes : Reese's peanut butter covered with a crunchy candy shell in a theater size box. These come in 3 colors: Brown, Orange and Yellow. Each box contains approximately 150 pieces."

Groovy Candies

$15.95

go to store
Mary Jane 24ct box

Mary Jane 24ct box

Peanut butter and molasses classic candy chews. 240 ct jar. Mary Jane are a delicious nostalgic candy from the 50's. Tasty bite size chewy peanut butter and molasses candies from Necco. ... more

Mary Jane 24ct box

Peanut butter and molasses classic candy chews. 240 ct jar. Mary Jane are a delicious nostalgic candy from the 50's. Tasty bite size chewy peanut butter and molasses candies from Necco.

YourCandyShop.com

$20.99

go to store
New Reese's Pieces 18 Count Box

New Reese's Pieces 18 Count Box

Reese's Pieces Peanut Butter Candy. Reese's Pieces are the creamy peanut butter filling of Reese's signature Peanut Butter cup in a crunchy shell. Enjoy Reese's Pieces by the handful and never worry about messy hands. Order the 1.53 ounce packages by... ... more

New Reese's Pieces 18 Count Box

Reese's Pieces Peanut Butter Candy. Reese's Pieces are the creamy peanut butter filling of Reese's signature Peanut Butter cup in a crunchy shell. Enjoy Reese's Pieces by the handful and never worry about messy hands. Order the 1.53 ounce packages by...

$20.95

go to store
Reeses Pieces 18ct box

Reeses Pieces 18ct box

Reese's Pieces Peanut Butter Candy. Reese's Pieces are the creamy peanut butter filling of Reese's signature Peanut Butter cup in a crunchy shell. Enjoy Reese's Pieces by the handful and never worry about messy hands. Order the 1.53 ounce packages by... ... more

Reeses Pieces 18ct box

Reese's Pieces Peanut Butter Candy. Reese's Pieces are the creamy peanut butter filling of Reese's signature Peanut Butter cup in a crunchy shell. Enjoy Reese's Pieces by the handful and never worry about messy hands. Order the 1.53 ounce packages by...

YourCandyShop.com

$16.99

go to store
Reese's Pieces New 18 Count Box

Reese's Pieces New 18 Count Box

Reese's Pieces Peanut Butter Candy. Reese's Pieces are the creamy peanut butter filling of Reese's signature Peanut Butter cup in a crunchy shell. Enjoy Reese's Pieces by the handful and never worry about messy hands. Order the 1.53 ounce packages by... ... more

Reese's Pieces New 18 Count Box

Reese's Pieces Peanut Butter Candy. Reese's Pieces are the creamy peanut butter filling of Reese's signature Peanut Butter cup in a crunchy shell. Enjoy Reese's Pieces by the handful and never worry about messy hands. Order the 1.53 ounce packages by...

The Candy City

$19.99

go to store
Mary janes theater size 12ct.

Mary janes theater size 12ct.

Mary Janes are a chewy molasses and peanut butter candy. Now sold in a theater size box, with a retro Mary Jane look. Mary Janes Theater Size Box - The Original, 12-3.5oz. Boxes. Mary Janes Theater Size 12ct. ... more

Mary janes theater size 12ct.

Mary Janes are a chewy molasses and peanut butter candy. Now sold in a theater size box, with a retro Mary Jane look. Mary Janes Theater Size Box - The Original, 12-3.5oz. Boxes. Mary Janes Theater Size 12ct.

Candy Crate

$26.99

go to store
Show
Hide
Hide