You're in Cakes & Pies

Need a Personal Shopper?

Subscribe to
Bizrate emails for the hottest
deals & products
,
PLUS a chance to

WIN $25

sign me up!

New winners chosen weekly.
No purchase necessary.

Peanut Butter Mousse Love Cake

Peanut Butter Mousse Love Cake

A celebration of chocolate and peanut butter in harmony! A layer of chocolate cake is heaped with peanut butter mousse swirled with delicious brownie and milk chocolate chunks, then topped with crunchy peanuts and covered with a luscious dark chocolate... ... more

Peanut Butter Mousse Love Cake

A celebration of chocolate and peanut butter in harmony! A layer of chocolate cake is heaped with peanut butter mousse swirled with delicious brownie and milk chocolate chunks, then topped with crunchy peanuts and covered with a luscious dark chocolate...

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)

$39.95

go to store

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)
Red Velvet, Cookie, & Peanut Butter Cake Pops - 12 Count

Red Velvet, Cookie, & Peanut Butter Cake Pops - 12 Count

Let Them Have Their Cake. And Cookies. And Peanut Butter Cups Too. This Gift Is All About The Decadent Details. We Mix Reeses Peanut Butter Sauce Into The Reeses Peanut Butter Cake Pops Then Finish Them Off With A Dark Dip And Peanut Butter Flavored... ... more

Red Velvet, Cookie, & Peanut Butter Cake Pops - 12 Count

Let Them Have Their Cake. And Cookies. And Peanut Butter Cups Too. This Gift Is All About The Decadent Details. We Mix Reeses Peanut Butter Sauce Into The Reeses Peanut Butter Cake Pops Then Finish Them Off With A Dark Dip And Peanut Butter Flavored...

Shari's Berries

(25,000+)

$34.99

go to store

Shari's Berries

(25,000+)
Peanut Butter Cake Pops Made With Reese's - 6 Count

Peanut Butter Cake Pops Made With Reese's - 6 Count

Chocolate And Peanut Butter. Our Reeses Cake Pops Take This Flavor Pairing To A Whole New Level Of Decadence. To Make Them We Mix Light, Fluffy White Cake With Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce And Then Finish It Off With Dark Dip And Peanut Butter Flavored... ... more

Peanut Butter Cake Pops Made With Reese's - 6 Count

Chocolate And Peanut Butter. Our Reeses Cake Pops Take This Flavor Pairing To A Whole New Level Of Decadence. To Make Them We Mix Light, Fluffy White Cake With Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce And Then Finish It Off With Dark Dip And Peanut Butter Flavored...

Shari's Berries

(25,000+)

$19.99

go to store

Shari's Berries

(25,000+)
Triple Mousse Cake - 1 x 6 cakes (4 oz each)

Triple Mousse Cake - 1 x 6 cakes (4 oz each)

We thank our lucky stars to have found this simply outstanding new line of gourmet desserts by Galaxy Desserts. Just amazing, they are made with the best natural ingredients and in a variety of flavors that are sure to satisfy everyone at the table.... ... more

Triple Mousse Cake - 1 x 6 cakes (4 oz each)

We thank our lucky stars to have found this simply outstanding new line of gourmet desserts by Galaxy Desserts. Just amazing, they are made with the best natural ingredients and in a variety of flavors that are sure to satisfy everyone at the table....

Amazon Marketplace

$35.90

go to store
Tastykake Peanut Butter Tandy Cake Family Pack (2 Per Pack-6 Packs Per Box)

Tastykake Peanut Butter Tandy Cake Family Pack (2 Per Pack-6 Packs Per Box)

(2) Tastykake Peanut Butter Tandy cake Family packs. 2 per pack-6 packs per box ... more

Tastykake Peanut Butter Tandy Cake Family Pack (2 Per Pack-6 Packs Per Box)

(2) Tastykake Peanut Butter Tandy cake Family packs. 2 per pack-6 packs per box

Amazon Marketplace

$9.00

go to store
Chocolate Mousse Torte Thank You Cake

Chocolate Mousse Torte Thank You Cake

Two rich, chocolate cake layers are filled with luscious chocolate whipped cream mousse, then covered with milk chocolate frosting and a dark chocolate glaze. This best selling delight is then garnished with fudge rosettes and dark chocolate shaves.... ... more

Chocolate Mousse Torte Thank You Cake

Two rich, chocolate cake layers are filled with luscious chocolate whipped cream mousse, then covered with milk chocolate frosting and a dark chocolate glaze. This best selling delight is then garnished with fudge rosettes and dark chocolate shaves....

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)

$39.95

go to store

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)
Red Velvet Thank You Cake

Red Velvet Thank You Cake

A southern classic, two rich red layers of chocolate cake, fill and cover with pure cream cheese frosting, and then garnish with white chocolate sprinkles around the sides. Includes an imported Belgian Chocolate Thank You Plaque, matching Greeting Card... ... more

Red Velvet Thank You Cake

A southern classic, two rich red layers of chocolate cake, fill and cover with pure cream cheese frosting, and then garnish with white chocolate sprinkles around the sides. Includes an imported Belgian Chocolate Thank You Plaque, matching Greeting Card...

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)

$39.95

go to store

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)
Tiramisu Classico Thank You Cake

Tiramisu Classico Thank You Cake

This delectable coffee-washed cake is two layers with classic mascarpone custard filling in between. The cake is then garnished with delicious coffee whipped cream, dark chocolate shaves and a dusting of cocoa... That s Amore! Includes an imported... ... more

Tiramisu Classico Thank You Cake

This delectable coffee-washed cake is two layers with classic mascarpone custard filling in between. The cake is then garnished with delicious coffee whipped cream, dark chocolate shaves and a dusting of cocoa... That s Amore! Includes an imported...

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)

$39.95

go to store

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)
Black and White Mousse Thank You Cake

Black and White Mousse Thank You Cake

Two moist chocolate cake layers sandwiched with heavenly clouds of classic whipped buttercream and decadent chocolate whipped cream, then enrobed in dark chocolate fudge frosting embellished with a white chocolate drizzle and covered with white... ... more

Black and White Mousse Thank You Cake

Two moist chocolate cake layers sandwiched with heavenly clouds of classic whipped buttercream and decadent chocolate whipped cream, then enrobed in dark chocolate fudge frosting embellished with a white chocolate drizzle and covered with white...

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)

$39.95

go to store

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)
Peanut Butter Mousse Congratulations Cake

Peanut Butter Mousse Congratulations Cake

A celebration of chocolate and peanut butter in harmony! A layer of chocolate cake is heaped with peanut butter mousse swirled with delicious brownie and milk chocolate chunks, then topped with crunchy peanuts and covered with a luscious dark chocolate... ... more

Peanut Butter Mousse Congratulations Cake

A celebration of chocolate and peanut butter in harmony! A layer of chocolate cake is heaped with peanut butter mousse swirled with delicious brownie and milk chocolate chunks, then topped with crunchy peanuts and covered with a luscious dark chocolate...

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)

$39.95

go to store

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)
Peanut Butter Mousse Happy Birthday Cake

Peanut Butter Mousse Happy Birthday Cake

A celebration of chocolate and peanut butter in harmony! A layer of chocolate cake is heaped with peanut butter mousse swirled with delicious brownie and milk chocolate chunks, then topped with crunchy peanuts and covered with a luscious dark chocolate... ... more

Peanut Butter Mousse Happy Birthday Cake

A celebration of chocolate and peanut butter in harmony! A layer of chocolate cake is heaped with peanut butter mousse swirled with delicious brownie and milk chocolate chunks, then topped with crunchy peanuts and covered with a luscious dark chocolate...

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)

$39.95

go to store

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)
Vanilla Bean Thank You Cake

Vanilla Bean Thank You Cake

A white on white delight! Two-layers of yellow cake are filled with clouds of vanilla whipped cream mousse, then covered with luscious buttercream and garnished with white chocolate and more mousse. Includes an imported Belgian Chocolate Thank You... ... more

Vanilla Bean Thank You Cake

A white on white delight! Two-layers of yellow cake are filled with clouds of vanilla whipped cream mousse, then covered with luscious buttercream and garnished with white chocolate and more mousse. Includes an imported Belgian Chocolate Thank You...

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)

$39.95

go to store

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)
Boston Cream Thank You Cake

Boston Cream Thank You Cake

A New England flavor delight right to the door of your loved one. Two moist and light layers of golden cake are filled with traditional French vanilla cream and topped with rich and delicious milk chocolate icing. Includes an imported Belgian Chocolate... ... more

Boston Cream Thank You Cake

A New England flavor delight right to the door of your loved one. Two moist and light layers of golden cake are filled with traditional French vanilla cream and topped with rich and delicious milk chocolate icing. Includes an imported Belgian Chocolate...

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)

$39.95

go to store

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)
Carrot Thank You Cake

Carrot Thank You Cake

THE BEST Carrot Spice Cake you ve ever tasted! Two moist carrot layers studded with walnuts and plump raisins, filled and frosted with rich cream cheese frosting. Includes an imported Belgian Chocolate Thank You plaque, matching Greeting Card and... ... more

Carrot Thank You Cake

THE BEST Carrot Spice Cake you ve ever tasted! Two moist carrot layers studded with walnuts and plump raisins, filled and frosted with rich cream cheese frosting. Includes an imported Belgian Chocolate Thank You plaque, matching Greeting Card and...

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)

$39.95

go to store

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)
Triple Chocolate Enrobed Browie Thank You Cake

Triple Chocolate Enrobed Browie Thank You Cake

Our moist & fudgy brownie cake goes through three chocolate passes before it s done: first it';s enrobed in rich chocolate fondant, then completely blanketed with a shower of dark chocolate shaves. Last, the cake is finished with milk and dark... ... more

Triple Chocolate Enrobed Browie Thank You Cake

Our moist & fudgy brownie cake goes through three chocolate passes before it s done: first it';s enrobed in rich chocolate fondant, then completely blanketed with a shower of dark chocolate shaves. Last, the cake is finished with milk and dark...

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)

$39.95

go to store

Bake Me a Wish

(1,000+)
Peanut Butter Cake Pops Made With Reese's - 12 Count

Peanut Butter Cake Pops Made With Reese's - 12 Count

Chocolate And Peanut Butter. Our Reeses Cake Pops Take This Flavor Pairing To A Whole New Level Of Decadence. To Make Them We Mix Light, Fluffy White Cake With Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce And Then Finish It Off With Dark Dip And Peanut Butter Flavored... ... more

Peanut Butter Cake Pops Made With Reese's - 12 Count

Chocolate And Peanut Butter. Our Reeses Cake Pops Take This Flavor Pairing To A Whole New Level Of Decadence. To Make Them We Mix Light, Fluffy White Cake With Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce And Then Finish It Off With Dark Dip And Peanut Butter Flavored...

Shari's Berries

(25,000+)

$34.99

go to store

Shari's Berries

(25,000+)
Red Velvet, Cookie, & Peanut Butter Cake Pops - 6 Count

Red Velvet, Cookie, & Peanut Butter Cake Pops - 6 Count

Let Them Have Their Cake. And Cookies. And Peanut Butter Cups Too. This Gift Is All About The Decadent Details. We Mix Reeses Peanut Butter Sauce Into The Cake Pops Then Finish Them Off With A Dark Dip And Peanut Butter Flavored Swizzles. Our Oreo Pops... ... more

Red Velvet, Cookie, & Peanut Butter Cake Pops - 6 Count

Let Them Have Their Cake. And Cookies. And Peanut Butter Cups Too. This Gift Is All About The Decadent Details. We Mix Reeses Peanut Butter Sauce Into The Cake Pops Then Finish Them Off With A Dark Dip And Peanut Butter Flavored Swizzles. Our Oreo Pops...

Shari's Berries

(25,000+)

$19.99

go to store

Shari's Berries

(25,000+)
Tastykake Kandy Bar Reese's Peanut Butter Creme Filled Cakes 3 Pack

Tastykake Kandy Bar Reese's Peanut Butter Creme Filled Cakes 3 Pack

This Tastykake favorite package includes 3 boxes of Tastykake Kandy Bar Kakes made with Reese's Peanut Butter. Kandy Bar Kakes are peanut butter cream filled chocolate cake. Each box includes 5 individually wrapped cakes for a total of 15 cakes per order. ... more

Tastykake Kandy Bar Reese's Peanut Butter Creme Filled Cakes 3 Pack

This Tastykake favorite package includes 3 boxes of Tastykake Kandy Bar Kakes made with Reese's Peanut Butter. Kandy Bar Kakes are peanut butter cream filled chocolate cake. Each box includes 5 individually wrapped cakes for a total of 15 cakes per order.

Amazon Marketplace

$24.49

go to store
Red Velvet, Cookie, & Peanut Butter Cake Pops - 6 Count

Red Velvet, Cookie, & Peanut Butter Cake Pops - 6 Count

Let them have their cake. And cookies. And peanut butter cups too. This gift is all about the decadent details. We mix Reeses® peanut butter sauce into the cake pops then finish them off with a dark dip and peanut butter flavored swizzles. Our Oreo®... ... more

Red Velvet, Cookie, & Peanut Butter Cake Pops - 6 Count

Let them have their cake. And cookies. And peanut butter cups too. This gift is all about the decadent details. We mix Reeses® peanut butter sauce into the cake pops then finish them off with a dark dip and peanut butter flavored swizzles. Our Oreo®...

Amazon Marketplace

$19.99

go to store
Mrs Freshleys Swiss Rolls Flavored with Reeses Peanut Butter, 2.8 Ounce -- 54 per case.

Mrs Freshleys Swiss Rolls Flavored with Reeses Peanut Butter, 2.8 Ounce -- 54 per case.

If you like cakes, and if you like creme, then you are going to love these delicious offerings from Mrs. Freshleys. From our icing topped Chocolate Cupcakes to our special Swiss Rolls, your sweet tooth will be head over heels Kosher View Nutrition Fact ... more

Mrs Freshleys Swiss Rolls Flavored with Reeses Peanut Butter, 2.8 Ounce -- 54 per case.

If you like cakes, and if you like creme, then you are going to love these delicious offerings from Mrs. Freshleys. From our icing topped Chocolate Cupcakes to our special Swiss Rolls, your sweet tooth will be head over heels Kosher View Nutrition Fact

Amazon Marketplace

$49.05

go to store
Tastykake Peanut Butter Kandy Kakes - Four Family Packs

Tastykake Peanut Butter Kandy Kakes - Four Family Packs

Whether you know them as Kandy Kakes or Tandy Kakes, these beloved treats combine a snack-sized circle of delicious vanilla or chocolate sponge cake, lined with a thick stripe of peanut butter or vanilla créme, and then coated in delicious chocolate... ... more

Tastykake Peanut Butter Kandy Kakes - Four Family Packs

Whether you know them as Kandy Kakes or Tandy Kakes, these beloved treats combine a snack-sized circle of delicious vanilla or chocolate sponge cake, lined with a thick stripe of peanut butter or vanilla créme, and then coated in delicious chocolate...

Amazon Marketplace

$19.49

go to store
Tastykake Cream Filled Kandy Bar Kakes with Reese's Peanut Butter - 5 CT

Tastykake Cream Filled Kandy Bar Kakes with Reese's Peanut Butter - 5 CT

2 Boxes of 5 individually wrapped creme filled cakes. Total of 10. ... more

Tastykake Cream Filled Kandy Bar Kakes with Reese's Peanut Butter - 5 CT

2 Boxes of 5 individually wrapped creme filled cakes. Total of 10.

Amazon Marketplace

$7.99

go to store
Tastykake Kandy Bar Kakes Made with Peanut Butter 4 Boxes

Tastykake Kandy Bar Kakes Made with Peanut Butter 4 Boxes

This Tastykake favorite package includes 4 boxes of Tastykake Kandy Bar Kakes made with Reese's Peanut Butter. Kandy Bar Kakes are peanut butter creame filled chocolate cake. Each box includes 5 individually wrapped cakes for a total of 20 cakes per... ... more

Tastykake Kandy Bar Kakes Made with Peanut Butter 4 Boxes

This Tastykake favorite package includes 4 boxes of Tastykake Kandy Bar Kakes made with Reese's Peanut Butter. Kandy Bar Kakes are peanut butter creame filled chocolate cake. Each box includes 5 individually wrapped cakes for a total of 20 cakes per...

Amazon Marketplace

$14.26

go to store
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Imagine the over-the-top combo of first-rate peanut butter cups chunked throughout our unparalleled creamy milk chocolate ice cream. Now add generous swirls of peanut butter ripple and you've topped perfection. The ideal dessert selection for any night... ... more

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Imagine the over-the-top combo of first-rate peanut butter cups chunked throughout our unparalleled creamy milk chocolate ice cream. Now add generous swirls of peanut butter ripple and you've topped perfection. The ideal dessert selection for any night...

Amazon Marketplace

$5.99

go to store
12 Pc. Assorted Brownie & Crumb Cake Sampler

12 Pc. Assorted Brownie & Crumb Cake Sampler

12 sumptuous 4 oz brownies and 6 oz. crumb cakes, individually wrapped and packaged in a gold David's Cookies tin. Brownie flavors include, Chocolate Chip, Pecan Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Cream Cheese, Rocky Road and Blondie. Crumb Cake flavors... ... more

12 Pc. Assorted Brownie & Crumb Cake Sampler

12 sumptuous 4 oz brownies and 6 oz. crumb cakes, individually wrapped and packaged in a gold David's Cookies tin. Brownie flavors include, Chocolate Chip, Pecan Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Cream Cheese, Rocky Road and Blondie. Crumb Cake flavors...

Amazon Marketplace

$39.95

go to store
Scott's Cakes 3 Inch Round Fluted Pastry Tart Shells - 6 Pack

Scott's Cakes 3 Inch Round Fluted Pastry Tart Shells - 6 Pack

Our ready to use pre-baked tart shells come in a variety of sizes. They are all made fresh with Real Butter and Fresh Eggs, then hand rolled and baked to perfection! You can use them for a variety of things, like a fruit tart filled with your favorite... ... more

Scott's Cakes 3 Inch Round Fluted Pastry Tart Shells - 6 Pack

Our ready to use pre-baked tart shells come in a variety of sizes. They are all made fresh with Real Butter and Fresh Eggs, then hand rolled and baked to perfection! You can use them for a variety of things, like a fruit tart filled with your favorite...

Amazon Marketplace

$6.25

go to store
Scott's Cakes 9.5 Inch Round Fluted Pastry Tart Shells - 2 Pack

Scott's Cakes 9.5 Inch Round Fluted Pastry Tart Shells - 2 Pack

Our ready to use pre-baked tart shells come in a variety of sizes. They are all made fresh with Real Butter and Fresh Eggs, then hand rolled and baked to perfection! You can use them for a variety of things, like a fruit tart filled with your favorite... ... more

Scott's Cakes 9.5 Inch Round Fluted Pastry Tart Shells - 2 Pack

Our ready to use pre-baked tart shells come in a variety of sizes. They are all made fresh with Real Butter and Fresh Eggs, then hand rolled and baked to perfection! You can use them for a variety of things, like a fruit tart filled with your favorite...

Amazon Marketplace

$13.95

go to store
Red Velvet Layer Cake

Red Velvet Layer Cake

Southern Secrets Revealed From Southern Family Reunions and Church Supper direct to you, the secret is out. Three brilliant layers of Christmas crimson, redolent of real creamery butter, fresh eggs, cocoa and vanilla and hand-frosted with our fluffy,... ... more

Red Velvet Layer Cake

Southern Secrets Revealed From Southern Family Reunions and Church Supper direct to you, the secret is out. Three brilliant layers of Christmas crimson, redolent of real creamery butter, fresh eggs, cocoa and vanilla and hand-frosted with our fluffy,...

Amazon Marketplace

$49.99

go to store
Scott's Cakes 3 Inch Round Fluted Chocolate Pastry Tart Shells - 12 Pack

Scott's Cakes 3 Inch Round Fluted Chocolate Pastry Tart Shells - 12 Pack

Our ready to use pre-baked tart shells come in a variety of sizes. They are all made fresh with Real Butter and Fresh Eggs, then hand rolled and baked to perfection! You can use them for a variety of things, like a fruit tart filled with your favorite... ... more

Scott's Cakes 3 Inch Round Fluted Chocolate Pastry Tart Shells - 12 Pack

Our ready to use pre-baked tart shells come in a variety of sizes. They are all made fresh with Real Butter and Fresh Eggs, then hand rolled and baked to perfection! You can use them for a variety of things, like a fruit tart filled with your favorite...

Amazon Marketplace

$11.95

go to store
Scott's Cakes 8 Inch Round Fluted Pastry Tart Shells - 12 Pack

Scott's Cakes 8 Inch Round Fluted Pastry Tart Shells - 12 Pack

Our ready to use pre-baked tart shells come in a variety of sizes. They are all made fresh with Real Butter and Fresh Eggs, then hand rolled and baked to perfection! You can use them for a variety of things, like a fruit tart filled with your favorite... ... more

Scott's Cakes 8 Inch Round Fluted Pastry Tart Shells - 12 Pack

Our ready to use pre-baked tart shells come in a variety of sizes. They are all made fresh with Real Butter and Fresh Eggs, then hand rolled and baked to perfection! You can use them for a variety of things, like a fruit tart filled with your favorite...

Amazon Marketplace

$46.95

go to store
Tastykake Chocolate Kandy Kakes - Four Family Packs

Tastykake Chocolate Kandy Kakes - Four Family Packs

Whether you know them as Kandy Kakes or Tandy Kakes, these beloved treats combine a snack-sized circle of delicious vanilla or chocolate sponge cake, lined with a thick stripe of peanut butter or vanilla créme, and then coated in delicious chocolate... ... more

Tastykake Chocolate Kandy Kakes - Four Family Packs

Whether you know them as Kandy Kakes or Tandy Kakes, these beloved treats combine a snack-sized circle of delicious vanilla or chocolate sponge cake, lined with a thick stripe of peanut butter or vanilla créme, and then coated in delicious chocolate...

Amazon Marketplace

$21.64

go to store
Tastykake Chocolate Kandy Kakes Family Pack - 12 CT

Tastykake Chocolate Kandy Kakes Family Pack - 12 CT

Tastykake's milk chocolate coated treats are beloved for their vanilla sponge cake lined with peanut butter or their chocolate sponge cake lined with vanilla cream. Whether eaten right out of the package or after being chilled (A "Tasty" secret!),... ... more

Tastykake Chocolate Kandy Kakes Family Pack - 12 CT

Tastykake's milk chocolate coated treats are beloved for their vanilla sponge cake lined with peanut butter or their chocolate sponge cake lined with vanilla cream. Whether eaten right out of the package or after being chilled (A "Tasty" secret!),...

Amazon Marketplace

$10.76

go to store
Show
Hide
Hide